2022’s Smile was a sleeper hit that took many by surprise, including me. While its premise on paper seemed simple—an entity spreading through trauma, marked by a sinister smile—the execution elevated it far beyond expectations. The film’s relentless tension, clever storytelling, and meticulously crafted lore kept me glued to the screen from start to finish. Naturally, when the sequel was announced, with Naomi Scott stepping into the lead role, my excitement was through the roof. And with the release of Smile 2, directed once again by Parker Finn, the big question is: can it live up to the original?

This time around, the infectious smile latches onto Skye Riley, a famous pop star played by Naomi Scott. The idea of a global sensation like Skye, who performs live in front of thousands of fans and potential carriers, is an ingenious way to up the stakes. The threat isn’t confined to a small circle anymore—Skye’s fame amplifies the potential devastation. It’s a high-concept idea that immediately feels fresh and relevant, adding a new layer of horror to an already terrifying premise.

Fortunately, the execution delivers on almost all fronts. Smile 2 successfully ratchets up the tension with grotesque imagery, visceral horror sequences, and a deeper dive into the lore of the malevolent entity. The film is unflinching in its depiction of the physical and psychological torment Skye endures, and Naomi Scott shines as the tortured lead, bringing depth and vulnerability to a character caught in a horrific spiral. The supporting cast also brings solid performances, complementing the intensity of Scott’s portrayal.

However, as strong as Smile 2 is, there are limitations inherent in any sequel. Much of the groundwork was laid in the first film, and while the lore is expanded, the sense of discovery isn’t quite as sharp this time around. The element of surprise that made the original so gripping has been somewhat diminished, simply because we’re now more familiar with the rules of the game.

All in all, Smile 2 stands tall as a worthy successor. It’s a thrilling, well-executed horror film that respects its predecessor while introducing fresh concepts. But despite its best efforts to expand the story, it doesn’t quite capture the raw impact of the first. Still, for fans of the original, it’s a must-watch—and for newcomers, it’s a chilling introduction to a franchise that has solidified itself as a modern horror staple.

P.S. My Letterboxd handle is @BhumikGrover.